Menu 

Cicero Indiana

 Latest Stories

Morse Reservoir at Cicero, Indiana, a suburb of IndianaCicero, Indiana, located due north of Indiana state capital Indianapolis and Noblesville, is a nice little Midwestern town with a population of 4,414 in 2006. Original settlers in the town go back as far as 1830, and the town was platted in 1834.

Morse Reservoir forms the focal point of most of its residential area, but Cicero is probably best known as the burial place of Ryan White, the national poster child for HIV/AIDS.

Ryan was kicked out of school because of his HIV infection, which he contracted through a contaminated blood treatment for his condition, like so many others in this sad epoch of humanity. This erupted into a high-profile legal fight against the public school system. It was during this melee that Ryan White became the famous spokesman for AIDS research and for educating the public about it. He died just before graduating from high school.

As did many of its small-town neighbors, Cicero experienced some success in its early years due to the plentiful natural gas reserves found throughout the area. Other businesses that became important to the prosperity of the town include a saw mill, glass factories, agriculture, and furniture and boot manufacturing. Shopping in Cicero may be mostly limited to the basics, but one can find some unusual items there too, thanks to the way Cicero business has developed over the years.

A major stream called Cicero Creek cuts through this pretty little town. The covered “Red Bridge” thatWelcom to Cicero, Indiana sign spanned it for years was a landmark, and is now only a memory. The streets of Cicero were brick-paved in the early 1900s, now a quaint memory as well. The charming downtown Cicero neighborhood huddles on the eastern edge of the beautiful Morse Reservoir.

The people of Cicero work hard to help their community grow and stay healthy. Today the town is flourishing right along with the high level of growth and prosperity of all the towns in Hamilton County, deemed one of the fastest-growing in the nation. Cicero is a busy and happy place, with self-sufficient amenities, ongoing events such as a kids’ carnival, holiday festivities and the big city of Indy just to the south for kicking up one’s heels.

Cicero Real Estate

 

1 East 226th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $109,000
Fantastic 10 lot subdivision being built by Vondersaar Homes. Each lot varies in topography and all located near a golf course, water and all within Hamilton Height school district. All are an easy commute to small towns or downtown Indy.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

00 East 226th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $159,000
Fantastic 10 lot subdivision being built by Vondersaar Homes. Each lot varies in topography and all located near a golf course, water and all within Hamilton Height school district. All are an easy commute to small towns or downtown Indy.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

6 East 226th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $149,000
Fantastic 10 lot subdivision being built by Vondersaar Homes. Each lot varies in topography and all located near a golf course, water and all within Hamilton Height School District. All are an easy commute to small towns or downtown Indy.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

2853 East 236th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

3 Beds 3 Baths - $599,900
Amazing and gorgeous 3 Bedroom 3 Bath Ranch sitting on 6.75 acres! This home is full of upgrades throughout! Totally neutral on the inside and move in ready! Check out the large kitchen with beautiful island and stainless appliances. Enjoy the 2 way fireplace. There are 2 bonus rooms above the garage with stairs to access the bonus rooms easily. This area is perfect for an office or extra storage. Large Master Suite has trayed ceiling, updated lighting and beautiful tiled shower. Home comes with a Geo-thermal heating and cooling system, hot water heater with supplelmental electric. Don't miss the finished basement that is perfect for entertaining. This home has so much charm and won't last long! Don't miss out!!!
Keller Williams Indy Metro NE

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

110 Cottonwood Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

2 Beds 2 Baths - $84,900
Well maintained 2 bdrm 2 full bath home in Hidden Bay. The home boasts a fenced in back yard, 2 storage sheds, and a carport connected to the home. Enjoy the private back deck overlooking the woods and fire pit. The home has been well kept with newer carpet, siding and windows. New roof and water heater 2 years ago. New HVAC 3 years ago. The home sits on a permanent foundation and you own the lot! Great investment opportunity and rents very easily.
Carpenter, REALTORS®

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

874 South Lanyard Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 4 Baths - $635,000
Custom-built, waterfront home on Morse Lake! Meticulously maintained & lavishly landscaped! You will be wowed by the breathtaking & peaceful setting. Enjoy lakefront living tucked away on a quiet cove while still having a panoramic view of the lake. Features: 2-story foyer & great rm, spacious kit w/breakfast bar & dining nook, 3 fireplaces, formal dining rm, main floor master suite & a screened porch where you'll want to spend your morning, noon & night. Full finished walk-out bsmt w/full bath, kitchen, & fam rm. Oversized garage has upper level, floored storage area. NEW roof/gutters, NEW high efficiency furnace, NEW On Demand hot water system, NEW water conditioner, NEW exterior paint & more! Hurry, so you can be on the water by summer!
Lady and Associates

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

715 Pleasant Point Circle, Cicero, IN 46034

5 Beds 4 Baths - $695,000
Own your piece of paradise on Morse Lake. This rare to find Lake Front 2-story w/expansive lake views has 5-beds, 3.5-baths, new spacious gourmet kitchen w/granite counter tops, Brazilian Teak HW floors, SS appliances, range hood, large center island w/seating & tons of storage. Access the impressive 52-ft deck overlooking the lake from the Master on the Main, great room, & dining room. Unwind in the sunroom w/lake views, sound of waves breaking gently on the shore, mature trees & nature to enjoy. You’ll love the flatness of the backyard. No steep steps to navigate to the water’s edge, small beach or boat dock w/covered lift for 24-ft pontoon. Finished walkout lower level with wet bar is perfect for entertaining. Home warranty included.
CENTURY 21 Scheetz

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

6950 East 226th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

6 Beds 6 Baths - $949,900
Beautiful, Rustic Home is now available in Hamilton Heights School District. This is a country vacation everyday on your land with creek while close to a golf course, pond and an easy commute to the city. This home features a huge, update kitchen over looking the pool, a great room with fireplace and great natural lighting as well as a cozy area to snuggle up to the fire. Upstairs is your master bedroom suite, loft area and three huge bedrooms with private lofts in each one. And you will love the walk out finished basement. So much to see that it is best done with a private tour.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

86 Cedar Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $349,000
We saved the best for last! This is the last vacant lake front opportunity on Morse Lake! 4.10 acres with 342 feet of lake frontage with absolutely breathtaking main channel views of Morse Lake! If you have been looking for an estate compound with the best lake views available in Central Indiana then this is the property for you! We invite you to come out and walk the property at your leisure to see how you would personalize this one of a kind lake opportunity! This is a MUST SEE now!
Highgarden Real Estate

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

23385 North Millcreek Road, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 5 Baths - $549,000
You are going to love this beautiful custom-built ranch home with finished lower level walkout on 2 1/2 acres! This home boasts a very large and open floor plan with 12ft ceilings in much of main level. The kitchen has been updated with new appliances and granite counters, very cozy hearth room adjoining kitchen and separate Great room! New roof in August of 2017, all new wood windows in 2011, new reverse osmosis filtration, new security system, home also has all the connections/hardware professionally installed to add a whole house backup generator! Please note, there is a staircase to the 800 sg ft attic over garage that has been insulated for an additional bonus room.
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

290 South Peru Street, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 2 Baths - $169,900
Beautiful Three/Four Bedroom Home in Downtown Cicero, Hamilton Heights School awaits its new owners. This home includes the lot behind it and features high ceilings and some original hardwood floors. When you walk in you will love the formal living room, a bedroom that can be used as an office, another room the owners used as the master bedroom suite, dining room, eat in kitchen and laundry room with extra storage. And you will love the two good size bedrooms upstairs with the loft. This home is in the light commercial zoning area of downtown. Walk to downtown and still be minutes to Indianapolis.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

809 Shoreline Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

2 Beds 2 Baths - $159,900
A short walk from morse reservoir, this custom built ranch with the red door is sure to win you over. Walk inside and you will be greeted by a large open concept living room lit up by the natural sunlight shining through the skylight that was installed in the vaulted ceiling. The kitchen flows from the living room and gives ample space to get dinner ready. If you step outside you'll be able to enjoy the backyard from a nice sizable deck. The master bedroom features an attached full bath and a nice walk in closet. This house also comes with a few modern features such as a keyless entry option and a Nest Smart Thermostat that will learn how you like your temperature throughout the day and adjust accordingly.
FRG Lafayette

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

23119 Sonoma Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

5 Beds 5 Baths - $599,000
STUNNING RANCH with fully finished walk out basement in popular Vintage Woods. This home has the perfect layout w/ Master suite & additional bedroom w/ on-suite on main level. Large open concept kitchen, formal dining & great room with views that will leave you in awe. Basement is 100% finished with 2 bedrooms that share a Jack-and-Jill full bath. Additional bedroom w/ on-suite in basement for your guests to privately enjoy space when visiting. Basement entertaining at its best with kitchen area and bar! The exercise room has a sauna that will remain in home. Home has private backyard, your own small creek & nature views throughout the year. Geothermal heating & cooling, Hot tub included (currently winterized) MORE PICTURES TO COME!
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

22585 Voss Hiatt Avenue, Cicero, IN 46034

3 Beds 2 Baths - $234,900
Beautiful home with 3 Bedrooms 2 Baths within Hamilton Heights School District in golf cart friendly Cicero, IN. Situated next to Community Park, you are within walking distance of the lake, library, and local downtown dining. This 3 bedroom brick ranch sits on the town limit line allowing extra potential. Renovations include new laminate wood floors, new furnace, and a new roof. There is a 2 car attached garage with new motor and door. Also included with the property is a detached 2 boat garage. Come take a look to see the charm of this town and this home for yourself.
Booker Realty

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

1130 Bear Cub Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 3 Baths - $459,900
Spacious custom two story beauty situated on over two acres in sought after Bear Slide. Featuring open floor plan inc. well equipped kitchen/breakfast room, great room w/fireplace, Den/LR, DR, Lovely MBR Suite w/ Large Walk In, Garden Tub, Sep Shower, Huge secondary BR's, Two have Walk-ins closets, Basement Features Family Rm, 18x18 Bonus Rm is Part/Fin - Great for Workshop, Basement plumbed for bath, Geothermal HVAC, Keep Utilities Low, 3 Car Garage, All of this and more on Outstanding well landscaped, acreage convenient to golf, schools & recreation.
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

16 Timber Ridge Court, Cicero, IN 46034

5 Beds 6 Baths - $590,000
Custom built spacious & spotless brick beauty in the trees on 1.48 acres in much desired Forest Estates w/deeded boat dock down the street. You can see Morse Lake from home! Well appointed eat in kitchen w/center island & Corian ctops - all applcs. stay! 4 seasons sunroom & screened in porch off kitchen. Formal dining room w/built in china cabinets! The grandest of GREAT rooms w/wood burning fireplace. Giant Master Suite upstairs w/walk in closet, double sinks, shower & jetted tub. 3 other spacious bedrooms upstairs - 1 w/own bath & 2 w/Jack n Jill bath - all w/walk in closets. Finished basement w/HUGE rec. room w/wet bar & wood burning fireplace. 5th BR downstairs along w/exercise, bonus & utility rooms - & full bath! 3 cgar & mini barn.
Carpenter, REALTORS®

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

5945 East 249th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 3 Baths - $499,000
Country charm with urban updates – this beautiful brick ranch on 3 private acres with an inground pool will wow you! Kitchen features custom island, gorgeous granite, tile back splash, and opens to spacious great room with cathedral ceiling and wood burning fireplace. Large formal dining room, and big master suite featuring walk-in closet and updated bath w/jetted tub. Hall bath has been completely redone! Walkout basement boasts huge family/rec room, large bedroom, fabulous new bathroom, amazing new bar area, bonus room and gigantic laundry room! Outdoor space is great for entertaining with sunroom, multiple porches, decks and balconies, and the pool! Rural living but minutes to US31 for easy access to Indy or anywhere! This is a MUST SEE!
RE/MAX Ability Plus

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

3034 Stilton Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 3 Baths - $196,000
"EPA Energy Star" endorsed; Quality features including 9' ceilings on main floor, gorgeous oak kitchen cabinets and counter space with large central island; French doors open to den/office with crown molding; brushed nickel hardware throughout; 5 burner smooth top electric range and side-by-side fridge; professionally painted + new carpet; tip-out double pane windows with wonder wood blinds; even a laundry chute to laundry room with utility sink! New roof will be installed prior to closing.
RE/MAX Ability Plus

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

23211 Anthony Road, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 5 Baths - $599,900
BEAUTIFUL! This awesome 4 bedroom, 3 1/2 bath custom home has so many updates on 7 acres with a woods and a creek ! This is a rare home on a hard to find park like setting in Hamilton County! The kitchen and bathrooms have granite counter tops, new tile, and lots of room. Enjoy fantastic views from many rooms in the home as well as the large deck and sun room areas! There are mature walnut trees throughout the woods, fire pits, and Hinkle Creek running through the back of the property. The full basement is newly finished including a large storage area and newly carpeted great room, bedroom and full bath with custom tile. The garage is an oversized 2 car garage with a workshop.
Weightman Realty Group, LLC

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

6100 East 249th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $275,000
Hard to find 10 Acres in Hamilton County. Perfect for a long drive and spacious home to be built. Bring your horses or custom builder. Close to the lake, not far from shopping, yet remote enough to enjoy quiet star lit nights.
Keller Williams Indy Metro NE

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

24049 Twilight Hills Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

3 Beds 2 Baths - $229,900
Charming ranch completely remodeled on almost 3/4 of an acre. Easy access to State Road 31, Grand Park, Carmel, Westfield, and Kokomo. Home has updated laminate flooring through-out, new appliances, heat pump, fresh paint, roof (2 yrs old). Large rec room has an amazing view to huge backyard. Don't miss out on this charming country setting home close to all the amenities.
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

1955 East 226th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

3 Beds 3 Baths - $1,400,000
Premier 20-acre equestrian facility! Conveniently located in Hamilton County near US 31, this spacious property features a remodeled 3 bedroom 2.5 bath home w/ hardwood floors, custom kitchen w/ granite, and 2 barns. The main barn was Amish-built in 2014, and boasts 18 stalls, 2 wash stalls w/ hot water, full bathroom, large tack room w/ heat/AC & commercial washer/dryer, & 1100 SF viewing area w/heat/AC and full kitchen that overlooks huge 82'x220' indoor riding arena. New LED lights have recently been installed. The 2nd barn is 30'x40' - perfect for large equipment storage. Property is fenced with oak, and includes an outdoor 140'x350' riding arena, and is cross-fenced with 6 large pastures. There are 2 separate wells and septic systems.
Carpenter, REALTORS®

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

4775 East 236th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

3 Beds 2 Baths - $295,000
Incredible Opportunity! Beautifully, Renovated Barn and Home on 5 Acres! MTV just finished Filming Their Recent Project here! Perfect for Weddings, Receptions and Large Gatherings! Home is the Original Farm House Built Featuring Original Hardwoods, Raised Ceilings and Unique Details Throughout! Main Level Master w/Plenty of Closet Space, Formal Dining Room, Eat-In Kitchen and Spacious Great Room. 2 Additional, Large Bedrooms on Upper Level as well Jack-n-Jill Bath, Loft and Home Office! Enjoy warm Summer Nights on the Front Porch! Lots of Privacy! Additional 25 Acres Available! Hamilton Heights School District!
RE/MAX Realty Services

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

0 East 236th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $275,000
Listing includes two parcels 1=20.acres, 1=5 acres (Total of 25 acres).
RE/MAX Realty Services

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

1140 Bear Cub Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 3 Baths - $449,900
GORGEOUS CUSTOM HOME by Vondersaar in PRESTIGIOUS BEAR SLIDE ON 2 ACRES! 2 stry entry, soaring clgs, open flr plan, dual stairway, beautiful hardwoods through main level. DEN w French doors, GR w gas frplc & blt in's on both sides, whole house audio, gourmet KIT, bk BAR w seating, BK RM plus formal DR w starburst clg, crn mldg, chair rail, incredible MSTR STE, Tray clg, tun + sep shwr, W/I w Sitting area/office & laundry, Full daylight LL plumbed for full BA ready to be finished. 3 C Gar. THIS HOME IS A MUST SEE! Minutes to shopping, restaurants and Morse Lake. VACATION YEAR ROUND!
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

9 Bayshore Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 2 Baths - $234,900
2 story home completely renovated in 2007, including new furnace, water heater, windows, doors, stainless steel kitchen appliances, Corian type solid surface countertops, cherry cabinetry, laminate flooring on upper level and tile surfaces on main level. Large Sunroom and upper deck for entertaining while viewing Mores Lake. 2 bathrooms, one with large 6 ft. garden Jacuzzi tub, 4 bedrooms, 2 gas fireplaces. Fenced in backyard, mature trees surround the rear deck. New roof, 2017. Home situated on oversized lot, convenient to all schools, parks, dining, shopping and recreational areas. Property is located 29 miles from downtown Indianapolis.
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

690 South Peru Street, Cicero, IN 46034

3 Beds 2 Baths - $79,900

F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

23224 Sonoma Lane, Cicero, IN 46034

4 Beds 6 Baths - $699,000
Immaculate custom, light filled home on private 1.67 acre wooded lot. Must be seen to fully appreciate the quality. Enjoy neighborhood activities or take a tranquil walk on your property along Bear Slide Creek. Main level living with first floor master suite with granite tops. Huge gourmet kitchen w/ granite, solid hickory cabinets, copper sinks, SS appliances & hidden microwave. Add closet doors to office and create a 5th bedroom. Screened porch. Hand-scraped solid hickory hardwood floors. Two stone fireplaces. Library. Large Mudroom. Tons of storage. Walkout basement with wet bar. Insulated basement slab for warmer floors. 3.5 Garage. 20 minutes to Carmel. Ask your Agent for the list of detailed information about this home in attachments.
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

22010 Us Hwy 31 N, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $321,650
9.19 acres total with multiple commercial zoning: 3 acres zoned C-2: general commercial development with moderate impact. Possible permitted uses: restaurants, recreational uses, antique/gift shops, public auction rooms. 6.19 acres zoned M-3: manufacturing extraction and processing. Permitted uses: concrete, asphalt plants and associated businesses. These two parcels are to be sold together, will not divide.
Kaiser Real Estate Corp.

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

22298 Us Highway 31, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $320,000
10 acres commercial land on US Highway 31, north of 216th Street. Zoned 0-1: "commercial use with bldg architecture and overall aesthetics of a "residential" character." Possible permitted uses: banks, financial institutions, offices, medical offices, self-storage facility as part of an office building or complex (size of storage facility cannot exceed size of office bldg.) Ingress/egress by small "farm cut" on east end of property.
Kaiser Real Estate Corp.

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

0 East 234th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $199,000
Rural Cicero in northern Hamilton County - Build your dream home on this 10 acre corner lot on beautiful land in a quiet country setting. Whether you are looking for a horse farm or just somewhere to raise farm animals, chickens, or 4-H livestock - this is it. Only 2 miles from Morse Lake with boat docks available in Cicero on the lake for summer fun. Easy commute for work at less than 3 miles to SR 37 with direct access to Indy or Marion.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

0 Overdorf Road, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $154,000
Rural Cicero in northern Hamilton County - Build your dream home on this 10 acre parcel on beautiful land in a quiet country setting. Whether you are looking for a horse farm or just somewhere to raise farm animals, chickens, or 4-H livestock - this is it. Only 2 miles from Morse Lake with boat docks available in Cicero on the lake for summer fun. Easy commute for work or less than 3 miles to SR 37 with direct access to Indy or Marion.
Keller Williams Indpls Metro N

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------

12693 East 256th Street, Cicero, IN 46034

0 Beds 0 Baths - $196,900
Excellent opportunity for small business. This building is 80x40 with over 3200 sq.ft. heated, cooled, insulated currently shop would make a great small manufacturing shop or office or storage for contractor, small vacant house is used for storage and not currently habitable.
F.C. Tucker Company

Call 317-578-3220 or click the address for details.


---------------------------------
Read about the top 5 Cicero restaurants
Children of Cicero
See articles and photos on hotels near Cicero